Random Reminder of the Day: UISwitch isOn vs. on – Object.property Is Not a Variable, It Is a Method.

I know that I should stop talking about objective-C. sorry.

It is interesting to see how coming into the Objective-C language in the last couple of years blinds you to some of the more traditional uses of the language. In particular the dot-syntax hides the underlying message passing model of objective-C. It is of course fully equivalent, but it is also compiler checked, which makes it easy to forget that @properties are merely getter/setter methods. Of course, we all learn that they are equivalent, but without the practice of coding without dot-syntax, it is easy to forget the implications.

I have been thinking about this recently, because I was contributing to an open-source project on github, and the coding in it was done almost entirely in braces-only syntax. It was an excellent exercise to stick with that entirely in my contributions. It was revealing to be constantly reminded that properties are not variables but methods.

To be explicit about this:

object.ivar = value

is not the same as

_ivar = value

but rather is equivalent to

[object setIvar:value]

The (trivial) spark of this post, was a target-action method from a UISwitch that I wrote, passing the UISwitch object as (id)Sender, and elsewhere, I had referred to the on/off property of my typed UISwitch object with switch.on = .... However, when I tried to type [sender on] for logging purposes, it was an error. I then typecast, logged, switch.on and it worked of course. But I was curious, and checked the documentation. Sure enough, it has a defined “isOn” getter method for the “on” property.

which means that

variable = switch.on;

is equivalent to

variable = [switch isOn];


variable = [switch on];

Anyway, this couldn’t be more basic, but it was a good reminder for me.


Now read this

On Learning Programming

Brian Kernighan and Dennis Ritchie in their classic The C Programming Language wrote that the biggest hurdle in starting beginning learning a programming language is to write a program to print the ‘Hello World’ on the screen, the rest... Continue →